Waiter, There's a '____' in my Soup!

[Kraetys]

Listen, that Gugi needed someone to love it, okay?!

Waiter, why is Josh Dun in my soup?!

Gosh dang it now I have to return this can of Josh Dun repellent!
Waiter why is there a party in my soup?

 

[Piano]

I thought you ordered the Party Zone special... Oh wait, I forgot PartyZone already IS special!

Waiter, why is my cat in my soup?!

 

[olookimshort]

Meow

Waiter, why is there a bagel in my soup?

 

[Piano]

I didn't have enough money for a wedding ring...

Waiter, why is Tem in my soup? tEm PaY 4 ColLeG

 

[olookimshort]

Never question Temmie ever again >:[

Waiter, why is my brother in my soup?

 

[Kraetys]

You see, you ordered alphabet soup, but the only letters font we had was comic sans.

Waiter why are there memes in my soup?

 

[olookimshort]

Cause who doesn't love memes?

Waiter, why is my phone in my soup?

 

[oop]

Shhh Can You Keep It For Me Im Hiding It From My Friend

Waiter Why Is Remmie Dressed Up As A Stitch In My Soup?

 

[Alliskn]

This stitch is special, and they really like soup.

Waiter, why is there a pokèball in my soup?

 

[Kraetys]

This stitch is special, and they really like soup.

Waiter, why is there a pokèball in my soup?

Please stop calling the Grimers soup and trying to eat them, I need one to complete my pokedex.
Waiter why is there a name in my soup?

 

[Ennuwaa]

You dont need to know my motives....
Waiter, there is a towel in my soup

 

[Kraetys]

You dont need to know my motives....
Waiter, there is a towel in my soup

Why is everyone calling my hot tub 'soup' and trying to eat it?
Waiter why is there a why in my soup?

 

[oop]

Cuz Why Not?

Waiter Why Is There Soap In My Soup

 

[Alliskn]

That was the soup bowl? I thought that was my bathtub.
Waiter, why is there toothpaste in my soup?

 

[Jesi]

The chef was brushing his teeth in the kitchen.

Waiter, why is there an emerald in my soup?

 

[Kraetys]

The chef was brushing his teeth in the kitchen.

Waiter, why is there an emerald in my soup?

It's collecting them so it can shoot the murderer.
Waiter why is there a knife in my soup?

 

[olookimshort]

Because in this world, it's KILL or be KILLED

Waiter, why is Flowey the flower in my soup?

 

[thatnewzealander]

Because I couldn't find anywhere to put him..

Waiter, why is there a jessICA @Skelebae In my soup?

 

[Jesi]

Bc @pandam44 left her chipotle in your soup, and I always need to steal it.

Waiter, why is there a kitchen sink in my soup?

 

[thatnewzealander]

Why not.

Waiter, why is there a LoL Stream in my soup?