Couldn't have said it better, Dabable you are talking about the same thing repetitively and it seems a bit fake.That doesn't make any sense at all. When you appeal to a court for breaking the law, you already know what law you've broken because you were in court the first time (in this case, banned/punished). The ban/punish message should tell exactly why a player has been banned, and then they can appeal if they believe they didn't deserve the punishment. Isn't that a lot easier and more simple?
That's just my opinion and it's just an idea. Feel free to disagree if you have a better idea.