Rejected Buying Fake Guns

[Hobali]

This came into my mind earlier on Team Speak during murder.

What if the murderer could buy a fake gun?

It would be differently coloured in a way from real guns, so that people can't assume that people without a gun are the murderer.

It would cost at least ten gems, as to where another knife costs five to make it fair.

Being able to point it out means different coloured sticks,or instead of iron/diamond/gold/wood/stone, another material; or make it wooden and just have people start at stone.


(Might be edited as comments possibly roll in)

 

[MariTheVillain]

except the server would then need to limit what varients of guns are available, as all material types for guns can be bought, and without resource packs, there isn't exactly a way to color the gun.

 

[allgoodstoobler]

The main purpose of a fake gun is to trick others into believing it is a real one. If you were to have a different colored gun, it would give it away and is almost impossible to even have different colored guns without a texture pack/mod.

 

[Timelord]

This came into my mind earlier on Team Speak during murder.

What if the murderer could buy a fake gun?

It would be differently coloured in a way from real guns, so that people can't assume that people without a gun are the murderer.

It would cost at least ten gems, as to where another knife costs five to make it fair.

Being able to point it out means different coloured sticks,or instead of iron/diamond/gold/wood/stone, another material; or make it wooden and just have people start at stone.


(Might be edited as comments possibly roll in)

Murder is based on Gmod murder. It's best to not change what it is meant to be. Also this completely makes murderer impossible to figure out. The only reliable way to defeat a good murderer if this was implemented would be to see the knife or sprint particles. Yet sprint particles aren't reliable due to fall particles. So just seeing the knife. And usually when you see it they throw it at you.
...
Murder doesn't need much changed unless something big is through up. Or the admins decide to take away the gmod aspect of murder. Also know that the murderer is very powerful compared to bystanders. Unless the bystander has a v4 the murderer wins if they know how to do it and follow the right paths. Maybe add a bystander idea and a murderer idea yet both equally powered yet not very powerful too.

 

[Kraetys]

Murder is based on Gmod murder. It's best to not change what it is meant to be. Also this completely makes murderer impossible to figure out. The only reliable way to defeat a good murderer if this was implemented would be to see the knife or sprint particles. Yet sprint particles aren't reliable due to fall particles. So just seeing the knife. And usually when you see it they throw it at you.
...
Murder doesn't need much changed unless something big is through up. Or the admins decide to take away the gmod aspect of murder. Also know that the murderer is very powerful compared to bystanders. Unless the bystander has a v4 the murderer wins if they know how to do it and follow the right paths. Maybe add a bystander idea and a murderer idea yet both equally powered yet not very powerful too.

V4 isn't enough to stop me.

 

[Harieo]

Due to the public rating of the suggestion and the fact that this change would completely change Murder as we know it (bringing it closer to other versions on other networks), I'm afraid we won't be implementing this. It may make Murder far too complicated as all tactics we know would fail.

Thank you for your suggestion though!