Murder New death

[Spetral]

My suggestion is a new death in murder.
The way to get the message at the end of the game will look astonishing but might make players fly off the handle when they are the murderer. When the murderer throws the knife at a wall, the knife should bounce and if the murderer doesn't move, the knife will hit the murderer and end his/her soul.(I mean to kill himself/herself in the game). To make this suggestion more detailed, the message should be green. Also, the knife doesn't have to hit the murderer only. It can bounce off the wall and hit the bystander or the detective as well. It should only bounce off the wall once. For example, I was the murderer. I am trying to go for the detective because he/she got the gun when he/she first spawned as a bystander. Say I tried to throw my knife at him/her and it hits the wall and then bounces off and hits me. I should then die because the knife hit me. Next, should say "The murderer was unsucessful!" Lets hope this get accepted



EVERYONE SHOULD BE LAUGHING!!!!!

MY REACTION WHEN I SEE A DONKEY

 

[Timelord]

My suggestion is a new death message in murder, "The murderer has accidentally killed itself!"
The way to get the message at the end of the game will look astonishing but might make players fly off the handle when they are the murderer. When the murderer throws the knife at a wall, the knife should bounce and if the murderer doesn't move, the knife will hit the murderer and end his/her soul.(I mean to kill himself/herself in the game). To make this suggestion more detailed, the message should be green. Also, the knife doesn't have to hit the murderer only. It can bounce off the wall and hit the bystander or the detective as well. It should only bounce off the wall once. For example, I was the murderer. I am trying to go for the detective because he/she got the gun when he/she first spawned as a bystander. Say I tried to throw my knife at him/her and it hits the wall and then bounces off and hits me. I should then die because the knife hit me. Next, the message that appears at the end should say, "The murderer has accidentally killed itself!" Lets hope this get accepted



EVERYONE SHOULD BE LAUGHING AT THE MESSAGE!

View attachment 5541




MY REACTION WHEN I SEE A DONKEY
View attachment 5542

The message isn't needed. Simply saying the murderer was unsuccessful is enough in my opinion. Boucing off walls would be a nice addition, yet what we have now is fine. The murderer killing themselves seems a bit far for just a fun game.

 

[Fox]

Seems a huge amount of work for a "Meme" way of killing people.
Also when a murderer kills themselves (By jumping off the map) or runs out of time, saying they were unsuccessful is alright.

Also a Con I could see of this is that the murderer might throw their knife by mistake or didn't mean to, it bounces off the wall, and kills them. Making it so they can't be murderer for a while. Also sometimes people just like to throw their knife a lot of the time just for the sound and if this was implemented that would take fun out of some players.

 

[Kraetys]

Would you like me to explain my downvote then?
Alright.

This would cause a few issues, for one, realism.
There is no possible way to throw something metal against a wall and have it bounce with enough accuracy to even hit them with the blade. Same with the amount of force used, even if you could hit them with the blade, you'd only cause superficial abrasions and no real damage.
There is no possible way you could throw something metal at an uneven wall and have it come back at you.
Even if the walls were flat, like in italy, most of the time those walls are soft enough for the knife to just stick in, and not too hard to remove the knife afterward.

Not to mention, mistakes happen. There are going to be a lot of unintended self killings.
A major change like this is going to make our player count bottom out faster than you can say Woodchucks.

This would completely change the balance of the game, making games more based on gambling than anything else.

And in the end, my view stays the same, don't fix what isn't broke.

 

[Zantoro]

My suggestion is a new death in murder.
The way to get the message at the end of the game will look astonishing but might make players fly off the handle when they are the murderer. When the murderer throws the knife at a wall, the knife should bounce and if the murderer doesn't move, the knife will hit the murderer and end his/her soul.(I mean to kill himself/herself in the game). To make this suggestion more detailed, the message should be green. Also, the knife doesn't have to hit the murderer only. It can bounce off the wall and hit the bystander or the detective as well. It should only bounce off the wall once. For example, I was the murderer. I am trying to go for the detective because he/she got the gun when he/she first spawned as a bystander. Say I tried to throw my knife at him/her and it hits the wall and then bounces off and hits me. I should then die because the knife hit me. Next, should say "The murderer was unsucessful!" Lets hope this get accepted



EVERYONE SHOULD BE LAUGHING!!!!!

View attachment 5541




MY REACTION WHEN I SEE A DONKEY
View attachment 5542

ehhh, I don't really see the point, sorry. To be honest, I don't really see the problem with how murder is at the moment.