Rejected "I Disagree" Button On Profile Page

[sweeteaa]

As you can see, @Kealily wrote that @Hclly is so pretty (which we all know is true), and I agree. Though you can spot that Hclly's comment disagree's with Kea and I want to dislike that message.
Just like @Cogitated | Logan's idea with the Like Button on comments, I think we should add a dislike button.

Feel free to comment extras and opinions

 

[kea]

A dislike button would actually be rlly good idea ;3

 

[teflonpresident]

I dont find a need for it...
-1 until theres a real reason.

 

[sweeteaa]

I dont find a need for it...
-1 until theres a real reason.

A dislike button would be useful for comments you disagree on, or opinions you dislike.

 

[Fox]

Ehhh +0

I'm staying neutral on this cuz yah it would be helpful but at the same time can end up some people getting Triggered and/or offended.

 

[xxx]

if this is added we'll be one step ahead of facebook +1

*angry react*

 

[ABennn]

Just simply the amount it would be spammed... +0 as the argument against it is strong enough.

 

[Liillii]

+0- I'm staying neutral on this.

See, in Holly's message she is being polite and not egotistical by not being like 'I know right!', so, if you were to dislike the message it would put neutral ratings on her profile for being nice. However, there are other uses for this and these uses would be beneficial.

 

[xxx]

+0- I'm staying neutral on this.

See, in Holly's message she is being polite and not egotistical by not being like 'I know right!', so, if you were to dislike the message it would put neutral ratings on her profile for being nice. However, there are other uses for this and these uses would be beneficial.

OP just used a bad representation of when this would actually be used. Think about the theory itself, not their example.

 

[Mine]

PZ is meant to be a family friendly, happy place. I garuntee someone's gonna get sad if their posts are disliked or hated and it will definitely cause some sort of drama. Plus there's gonna be one kid who spams it to be a troll or because they hate someone.

 

[Liillii]

OP just used a bad representation of when this would actually be used. Think about the theory itself, not their example.

That's why I said; 'However, there are other uses for this and thaws uses would be beneficial."

 

[Timelord]

-1 This is like the I disagree button.
Simply use the I disagree button instead. As stated above people would abuse it and other things as well.
It would be nice to have yet it's better to have a neutral rating than a negative one.

 

[Mine]

Also if there's a post you don't like you can use the report button if they're breaking a rule <o/

 

[Ameliq]

I really think that "Disagree" is enough and that there's no real need for a dislike button. -1

 

[Lewie]

-1,

Agreed with all other comments.

 

[reddd]

-1. It'll cause controversy, and i think this server doesn't wanna end up like any of the other miserable servers with a dislike button, where no-one's friends.

 

[aiden]

-1 This is like the I disagree button.
Simply use the I disagree button instead. As stated above people would abuse it and other things as well.
It would be nice to have yet it's better to have a neutral rating than a negative one.

I believe the OP means 'dislike' in the context of disagree, as a neutral rating. Correct me if I'm wrong @Amoraa

Just simply the amount it would be spammed... +0 as the argument against it is strong enough.

Hold on a second. If someone truly wanted to spam dislikes, all they need to do is look at someone's recent posts and use 'I Disagree' on them. Therefore, this argument is proven invalid since it already could happen.

-1. It'll cause controversy, and i think this server doesn't wanna end up like any of the other miserable servers with a dislike button, where no-one's friends.

Is "controversy" being used in the context of a dispute, or an overall unpleasant reaction by the majority of the members of the forum? I'm not sure how to respond without knowing the context this certain word is being used in.
Also, adding a dislike/disagree button won't mean that nobody is friends, that's an unrealistic exaggeration.

I really think that "Disagree" is enough and that there's no real need for a dislike button. -1

Actually, I'd beg to differ. Let's say that you're having a conversation with someone else about something and you disagree with something they say. It's easier to rate their comment as such and then explain why you disagree.

+0- I'm staying neutral on this.

See, in Holly's message she is being polite and not egotistical by not being like 'I know right!', so, if you were to dislike the message it would put neutral ratings on her profile for being nice. However, there are other uses for this and these uses would be beneficial.

Then possibly make it so that it does not add to the neutral rating count, just like how posts in the Forum Games section don't count.

 

[ABennn]

Hold on a second. If someone truly wanted to spam dislikes, all they need to do is look at someone's recent posts and use 'I Disagree' on them. Therefore, this argument is proven invalid since it already could happen.

Yes, and people already do that. So this would cause more dislikes to be spammed. Especially since it's easier to get to the posts, people will spam dislikes.
But what you said here:

Then possibly make it so that it does not add to the neutral rating count, just like how posts in the Forum Games section don't count.

Then why do it at all? If it's not going to count, and just sit there and do nothing, then why do it at all?

I'm staying +0, I see no need for this and no need to have little kids look in their notifications and see 'AnEmeraldAndTea disliked your comment on AnEmeraldAndTea's profile post.' And have them become angry or sad over something.

Just my opinion, if someone finds a genuine need for this then I'd consider agreeing with this.

 

[aiden]

Yes, and people already do that. So this would cause more dislikes to be spammed. Especially since it's easier to get to the posts, people will spam dislikes..

Then report them.

Then why do it at all? If it's not going to count, and just sit there and do nothing, then why do it at all?.

Just for convenience. Just to say you disagree with somebody.

 

[Timelord]

Does she want the I disagree button to be replace by the dislike button? This is just confusing lol can someone make a clear basic idea of this?